Abaye asks a kasha on Rava from Meducha and Eli; but haven’t we learned earlier that these objects are considered ‘Chisaron Kis’ and cannot be moved regardless?
Quick Search:
Quick Search Daf Insights:
Abaye asks a kasha on Rava from Meducha and Eli; but haven’t we learned earlier that these objects are considered ‘Chisaron Kis’ and cannot be moved regardless?
That was only said about the Eli, not the Maducha. Regardless, it was a Terutz, an attempt to understand why it should be Assur. Rabba suggested equating it with item that are actually much heavier than the Eli. Tosafos said about these answers on Madusha and Eli that Abaye, although he already heard the answers from Rabba, asked them again in case he’ll get a better answer.