I left a replay a few days ago about the HTML/XML error in your code and that I cannot download the MP3 of daf yomi shiurim. I need to download the MP3 for portability. It is still broken and I have not received a reply:
This XML file does not appear to have any style information associated with it. The document tree is shown below. AccessDeniedRequest has expired2017-08-23T03:19:37Z2020-01-22T14:26:21Z6740168B42E6457Dv87gD8RDXvXBuQy0ZPZkERU4jzCaDDXQzApKsOR9sXKAaaAnPLGB3eecvZlPIR5/ohl2ZUL74hE=
Rebbe,
We know takkanas Ezra was rescinded because ayn hatzibbur yachol laamod bs. How long did that take to be established? Is there a rule for such a time span?
The Ramba”m (Hilchos Mamrim 2:6,6) writes that there is no timeframe, even if it was accepted for a period of time and then is no longer being practiced, it can be rescinded.
Interestingly regarding Tevilas Ezra, the Ramba”m (Hilchos Krias Shema 4:8) indicates that from the onset it never took off.
It certainly sounds from our Gemara that Rebbi Yehuda ben Beseira annulled it, however, please have a look as the Ramba”m (Hilchos Tefillah 4;4,5) where again he indicates that there was no formal annulment, rather merely a result of non-adherence. Same in Tosfos (Bava Kamma 82b d”h Asa,) in the third teirutz, seems that the circumstance was merely confirmed and formalized by Rebbi Yehuda ben Beseira.
I left a replay a few days ago about the HTML/XML error in your code and that I cannot download the MP3 of daf yomi shiurim. I need to download the MP3 for portability. It is still broken and I have not received a reply:
This XML file does not appear to have any style information associated with it. The document tree is shown below.
AccessDeniedRequest has expired2017-08-23T03:19:37Z2020-01-22T14:26:21Z6740168B42E6457Dv87gD8RDXvXBuQy0ZPZkERU4jzCaDDXQzApKsOR9sXKAaaAnPLGB3eecvZlPIR5/ohl2ZUL74hE=Rebbe,
We know takkanas Ezra was rescinded because ayn hatzibbur yachol laamod bs. How long did that take to be established? Is there a rule for such a time span?
Gut Voch R’ Shmuel,
The Ramba”m (Hilchos Mamrim 2:6,6) writes that there is no timeframe, even if it was accepted for a period of time and then is no longer being practiced, it can be rescinded.
Interestingly regarding Tevilas Ezra, the Ramba”m (Hilchos Krias Shema 4:8) indicates that from the onset it never took off.
Hatzlacha
It certainly sounds from our Gemara that Rebbi Yehuda ben Beseira annulled it, however, please have a look as the Ramba”m (Hilchos Tefillah 4;4,5) where again he indicates that there was no formal annulment, rather merely a result of non-adherence. Same in Tosfos (Bava Kamma 82b d”h Asa,) in the third teirutz, seems that the circumstance was merely confirmed and formalized by Rebbi Yehuda ben Beseira.